Best Local Boutiques and Artisan Markets to Support This Holiday Season

Holiday shopping in and around Southampton hits different—twinkle lights on Jobs Lane, friendly shopkeepers who remember your last purchase, and gifts with real stories behind them. You don’t need a city trip or a big-box search; within a quick thirty-minute drive, you’ll find historic general stores, fashion-forward boutiques, and maker markets that turn checking off your list into an afternoon you’ll actually look forward to. Below are our go-to spots—each open to the public—where you can browse calmly, buy thoughtfully, and keep your dollars right here at home.

Hildreth’s Home Goods

If you love gifts with heritage, start at Hildreth’s—often cited as America’s oldest continuously run department store. Inside, you’ll find a deep, curated selection of bedding, bath, tableware, candles, and coastal-casual home accents that feel tailor-made for Hamptons hosts. It’s the rare place where you can outfit a whole guest room and still pick up stocking stuffers at the register. The staff is famously helpful, and the Main Street location makes it easy to bundle with other stops. For the history buffs in your crew: Hildreth’s has been part of Southampton’s shopping DNA since 1842, which makes every purchase feel a little like taking home a piece of local lore. 

TENET

For the fashion-forward friend or the one spectacular gift moment, head to TENET. This lifestyle boutique brings a sharp, Hamptons-meets-global edit of premium apparel, footwear, accessories, and apothecary—think beautifully made staples with a modern edge. It’s an easy browse: clean layout, helpful associates, and a mix that works for both everyday wear and special occasions. We love it for quality pieces that outlast trends (and look great in a bow-tied box). The shop sits right on Main Street, so you can park once and make a full Southampton stroll of it.

Collette Designer Consignment

If your gifting style leans unique and sustainable, Collette Designer Consignment is a treasure hunt you won’t want to miss. Expect rotating racks of authenticated luxury fashion and accessories, plus a sister home store nearby for distinctive décor finds. Holiday timing is prime—new consignments arrive frequently, and you can score everything from a statement winter coat to a coffee-table conversation piece. The team knows their inventory cold and can help you match taste, size, and budget. Shopping pre-loved luxury is both eco-smart and delightfully personal.

Flying Point Surf & Sport

Gifts for the beach-to-village crowd live here. Flying Point Surf & Sport blends surf culture with approachable designer brands—great sweats, beanies, outerwear, and accessories—plus practical gear for year-round coastal life. It’s the spot for the teen who wants the right hoodie, the weekend warrior who needs a warm layer, or the friend who basically lives in joggers. Two Southampton storefronts make it easy to pop in while you’re already downtown. If you’re building a themed gift, pair a cozy fleece with a stocking stuffer from their accessories wall and call it a win.

The Church: Holiday Makers Market

A quick hop to Sag Harbor brings you to The Church—an inspiring arts space in a beautifully restored 19th-century building—whose annual Holiday Makers Market showcases a curated roster of local artisans. You’ll find small-batch jewelry, textiles, ceramics, fine art, and more, often with the maker right there to chat about process and materials. It’s an unfussy, joyfully creative atmosphere that makes gift-finding feel like discovery, not duty. Dates are typically announced each fall; check their site for this year’s schedule before you roll. Pro tip: build in time to explore the village afterward—there are plenty of cafés for a celebratory cocoa.

Southampton Arts Center: Holiday Fair

Prefer to keep your market day right in the village? The Southampton Arts Center hosts a festive Holiday Fair with local vendors, live music vibes, and easy parking just behind the building—perfect for a one-stop shop loop. Expect artisan gifts, seasonal décor, and edible treats from East End makers, all under one roof. The fair is a beloved annual happening, so watch their calendar or the Chamber’s event listings for specific dates and hours. Between purchases, pop into the galleries—the Center’s exhibitions and programs run year-round, and admission to the gallery is often free.
 

Local Holiday Shopping Around Southampton

Holiday gifting around Southampton is as local and lovely as you make it—historic Main Street icons, fashion boutiques with serious taste, and maker markets where every table tells a story. With short drives and walkable blocks, you can cover everyone on your list while supporting neighbors and artists who keep our community vibrant. Map your route, grab a warm drink, and enjoy the glow of small-town shopping done right. And when you’re cruising between stops—whether you’re loading décor from Hildreth’s or picking up artisan finds after the market—Mercedes-Benz of Southampton is here to keep your holiday season smooth, comfortable, and confidently on time.