Mercedes-Benz vs. Lexus: Which Brand Offers More for Long Island Drivers?

There's a stiff battle of the brands between Mercedes-Benz vs. Lexus, with compelling competitors on both sides. While both automakers can deliver a quality vehicle, the most compelling features of a Benz are difficult to find elsewhere. Mercedes-Benz has prestige that few automakers can touch. Here's what you need to know about your options on both sides of this debate.

Mercedes-Benz vs Lexus: Understanding the Differences

​
Image by Rama Laksono is licensed with Unsplash License

Mercedes-Benz and Lexus are both leaders in the luxury automotive industry. Both brands are known for their craftsmanship, performance, and elegant details. Competition is stiff in this battle of the brands, but there are some distinct differences worth noting.

Lexus and Mercedes-Benz may seem similar because of their proximity in the auto industry, but they're very different brands. Lexus was founded by Toyota chairman Eiji Toyoda in 1989. This Japanese car brand was established as the luxury arm of Toyota. The flagship Lexus LS 400 was unveiled the same year, and numerous luxury car and luxury utility vehicle models have followed.

Mercedes-Benz has a much longer history. The Daimler-Benz AG company was founded in 1926 as a collaboration between Karl Benz, Gottlieb Daimler, Wilhelm Maybach, and Emil Jellinek. The German car manufacturer became the largest premium vehicle brand in the world in 2018, selling 2.31 million passenger cars.

Drivers choose Lexus for reliability. These cars are comfortable with many appealing features. The main selling point here is dependability. Mercedes-Benz excels in engineering. A Benz offers superior driving dynamics and brand cachet.

Performance & Driving Experience: Mercedes-Benz Leads with Engineering

Mercedes-Benz is known for its superior engineering with an emphasis on responsive handling and refined powertrains. A Benz gives Long Island drivers confident acceleration on the LIE and comfortable cruising along the Montauk Highway. You'll enjoy dynamic driving and state-of-the-art tech that elevate your experience whether you're navigating Southampton village or headed into the city.

Mercedes-Benz engineering is well-equipped for winter weather. The brand's 4MATIC AWD system continuously monitors road conditions and responds intelligently to maintain maximum control. The system optimally engages all four wheels to respond immediately to changing conditions.

Lexus prioritizes comfort over performance. You'll get a smooth ride but won't enjoy the same engine diversity or performance excitement. Steady and subdued, Lexus prioritizes value and dependability over the thrill of the road.

Interior Luxury, Craftsmanship & Technology

Mercedes-Benz strives to provide an immersive luxury experience. You'll find yourself cocooned in high-end materials with thoughtful ambient lighting and intuitive integrated tech. The MBUX system adapts to each user and provides a perfectly personalized experience. Lighting, temperature, seat massage settings, and more are saved per user so the vehicle can deliver an amazing experience every time you slide behind the wheel. A "Hey, Mercedes" is all it takes to activate voice controls for quick and convenient adjustments. This takes comfort to the next level, whether you're cruising along your daily commute or headed to the Hamptons.

Lexus takes a more conservative approach to its technology. While it offers a well-rounded infotainment system, including voice recognition with its multimedia setup, it doesn't leverage AI the way Benz is starting to. Traditional designs take precedence.

Safety, Driver Assistance & Innovation

Lexus and Mercedes both offer outstanding safety features. Mercedes-Benz has consistently remained at the forefront of technological innovations. The automaker pioneered the crumple zone in 1951, filed the patent for the airbag in 1971, and developed the Antilock Braking System (ABS) in 1978. More recently, Benz debuted night view assist in 2005 and surround view systems in 2012.

Today's Mercedes-Benz vehicles make use of the carmaker's patented PRE-SAFE system that anticipates accidents and responds by adjusting seatbelts, headrests, and windows accordingly. The Active Driving Assist DISTRONIC technology maintains a safe distance between your vehicle and the one ahead. ATTENTION ASSIST helps monitor the driver's level of fatigue to alert you when it's time to rest.

The Lexus Safety System+ suite includes a range of standard safety features like a pre-collision system, dynamic radar cruise control, and proactive driving assist. Safety Connect assistance can deploy assistance to the scene using your GPS location if you're in an accident.

The Top Safety Pick+ designation was awarded to the 2025-26 Mercedes-Benz C-Class 4-door sedan, GLC 4-door SUV, and GLE-Class 4-door SUV. The Top Safety Pick+ designation only went to the 2026 Lexus NX 4-door SUV.

Ownership Experience & Satisfaction

Mercedes-Benz leads the charge for performance and prestige. Benz drivers enjoy a premium service experience that's in line with the brand's commitment to luxury. You'll have access to high-end loaners, meticulous maintenance services, and strong resale value. Mercedes-Benz of Southampton, like many Mercedes dealerships, offers a comfortable lounge for guests to enjoy while their vehicles are being serviced. We have equipped our waiting area with high-speed WiFi, a large-screen television, and complimentary premium coffees, teas, and snacks.

Lexus vehicles are known for their reliability and low maintenance costs. You'll enjoy functionality and affordability, but less in the way of premium luxury. There's less prestige to inform the resale value, so you would typically sell a Lexus in a different market than a Mercedes-Benz. Lexus does well for drivers who want stability and budget-friendly service, but Mercedes-Benz enjoys the distinction of demand. The SUV and AMG variants are in especially high demand in the Long Island pre-owned market.

Final Verdict: Why Mercedes-Benz Fits Long Island Drivers Better

While Lexus is a solid contender in the automobile market, Mercedes-Benz offers more luxury, class, performance, and prestige for Long Island drivers. If you're shopping for a standout vehicle that will feel right at home in the Hamptons, a Benz is the best pick. You'll get superior performance, cutting-edge technology, class-leading safety, and a refined design. Visit Mercedes-Benz of Southampton to test-drive your favorite model and discover why so many Long Island drivers choose this car brand.